Hi all, I am new to this forum but have been making wootz since around 2002 when I was living in Tennessee. I know that's not long compared to some. I think it is a good idea to come up with a popular definition of wootz, at least among ourselves. If we don't come up with at least a basic terminology for what it is we make, then someone else will and we may not like what it is.
I kind of like the definition which Anna Fauerbach came up with, which refers to wootz as being the loose process, and the patterns as being from different regions (from slightly different methods and composition).
Personally, I have found that the pattern on every piece of steel comes out slightly different. Just like you Ric I can find two pieces from next to each other in a bar that end up completely different. The stuff that I like to make, most often has a rather strong dendritic structure, this I currently call patterned crucible steel. It is from the same ingots as my Persian patterned wootz but treated in a completely different way. The dendritic looking stuff is more like the turkish style of wootz. The pattern also changes by how long the bar is drawn out and if it is hit equally on both sides of the bar.
To further confuse the issue I have fallen into the practice of not grinding off the final decarb from the finished blade before etching. This takes a much deeper etch and creates a negative pattern which seems to be more wear and rust resistant. As a result, although the blades are really like turkish style wootz and probably should be called that, I have been refering to them as patterned crucible steel. It is a very broad category I know.
It would be really good to put up an online collection of good quality photos of the patterns of traditional blades with the locations that the blades were made. To be used as a comparison and an aid in description for the patterns we come up with. It would also help to be able to identify some of the variations of process that were used in the past.
If any of you have good pictures of the patterns from old blades I would be happy to put them up on my site.
I know that not everyone will be happy with everything in the final definition, but that is the way with anything.
Just my ten cents worth!
Tim.