owen bush Posted April 4, 2019 Posted April 4, 2019 well 6 years on (time really flys) I do almost all of my billet welding in a gas forge without any flux. It is certainly a better process. the dis advantage is some grinding... it takes longer in total time than when folding under the hammer , but is slightly less "work time" if you do not count time hreating. however the welds are certainly better and not using borax is sooooooo much better for my health and forge! the only time I now personally use flux is when teaching hand forge welding or for final welds on multi bar billets...I can do small ones fluxless but use flux when the billet is longer than the forge.... its a great improvement.....big thanks to JD and others who put this out there... forging soul in to steel owenbush.co.uk
Robert D. Posted April 5, 2019 Posted April 5, 2019 I just finished relining my propane forge, and plan to give this process a try this weekend, I have two completely full bottles of propane and two completely prepped billets ready to go for this test. I am going to try one with Kerosene and one with WD40, just to try both out and to see if there is any adverse reaction to my forge lining ( ITC100 and Satanite ) because having the forge down for days is a drag. http://robertjamescustoms.tumblr.com/
Gary Mulkey Posted April 7, 2019 Author Posted April 7, 2019 On 4/4/2019 at 12:56 PM, owen bush said: the only time I now personally use flux is when teaching hand forge welding or for final welds on multi bar billets...I can do small ones fluxless but use flux when the billet is longer than the forge.... I will occasionally coat a blade with a little borax when normalizing just to hold down the scale. That's the only use of it that I've had for many years. Gary ABS,CKCA,ABKA,KGA
Robert D. Posted April 9, 2019 Posted April 9, 2019 Well, Both of my attempts failed. odd thing is when I pulled the billets apart, they were nice and clean still. So I think my Propane forge just wasnt hot enough, it was in the mid to high orange range, One billet was 15N20 and W2, and the other was 15N20 and 1084. Thankfully I didnt try to force them to weld by hitting them stupid hard, so they are both still nice and straight and clean, so its just a matter of cleaning up the mating surfaces and giving it another go. But now I have to figure out why my propane forge isnt getting hot enough. http://robertjamescustoms.tumblr.com/
Robert D. Posted April 9, 2019 Posted April 9, 2019 I think I just figured out what my issue might be with my propane forge. Its a very small forge, venturi style burner with firebricks front and back to cover the openings. So I started reading https://ronreil.abana.org/troubleshooting.shtml And I noticed where he says that one of the most common issues with propane forge welding is backpressure, I have two full bricks flush on the back blocking it entirely, and only keeping a small gap about the width of the handle between the bricks in the front. So now I plan to go home and finish slotting my bricks for work placement and then perhaps I may fire the badboy up and give it another go. http://robertjamescustoms.tumblr.com/
Joshua States Posted April 13, 2019 Posted April 13, 2019 I never added my bit to this thread. I tack weld my billet up and weld it to a handle and it goes straight into a 5-gallon bucket of diesel fuel. (Shell, low octane) it sits there until I light the forge and it comes up to about 800 F or so and then it goes right into the forge. Don't ask me why, but it seems to keep the scale down and I never have any problems with weld flaws or inclusions. I used to use a little flux on the flat parts so I could "read" the flux and know when to weld, but now I have the thermocouple and digital readout. “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Paul Carter Posted June 15, 2020 Posted June 15, 2020 I spray my billets down with WD40 before putting in forge to forge weld. I make sure all mating sides are clean and flat. Haven't had a bad weld yet. No inclusions either. I have never used flux.
Garry Keown Posted July 22, 2020 Posted July 22, 2020 On 4/13/2019 at 2:16 PM, Joshua States said: I never added my bit to this thread. I tack weld my billet up and weld it to a handle and it goes straight into a 5-gallon bucket of diesel fuel. (Shell, low octane) it sits there until I light the forge and it comes up to about 800 F or so and then it goes right into the forge. Don't ask me why, but it seems to keep the scale down and I never have any problems with weld flaws or inclusions. I used to use a little flux on the flat parts so I could "read" the flux and know when to weld, but now I have the thermocouple and digital readout. So are you running it in the 22-2300 range Joshua as mentioned back in the thread a ways. Von Gruff http://www.vongruffknives.com/ The ability to do comes with doing.
Joshua States Posted July 22, 2020 Posted July 22, 2020 (edited) 5 hours ago, Garry Keown said: So are you running it in the 22-2300 range Joshua as mentioned back in the thread a ways. I try to hit 2450 F, but I have found that 2250 or above and I can weld 1095, 15N20, or W2 just fine. The most important thing is getting the entire billet up to temp. I usually start with pretty high layer counts for my Damascus (21-25). So the center takes a lot longer to heat. Edited July 22, 2020 by Joshua States 1 “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Brian Dougherty Posted July 22, 2020 Posted July 22, 2020 My experience matches Joshua's pretty well. My forge maxes out at a little over 2300F depending on the day. I do a lot with 1084 or 1095 mixed with 15N20, and that all welds up fine with no flux as long as I am over 2200F. I judge the temperature of the billet by watching the color of the thermocouple tip, and taking a reading when the tip color matches the billet color. Alternatively, I'll tuck the tip of the thermocouple probe in the "Shadow" of the billet so that it isn't exposed to the flame. The forge will never be the exact same temperature all over. It is important to know the temperature of the steel, not the forge. If you have ever smoked meat, and used an internal thermometer to measure the temperature of your meat, you'll know how long it takes for the center of something to get to the oven temperature. The closer the oven (forge) temperature is to your target temperature, the longer it takes for the heat to move to the center of the billet. I do some pretty long soaks on a 2" thick billet before I set the weld. I don't time them, but I bet I wait 15 minutes after the surface of the billet is at welding temp. 1 -Brian
Dick Sexstone Posted October 26, 2022 Posted October 26, 2022 Cool thread… thought provoking for me…. I only have a coal forge and with a large billet I run out of fuel before reaching temperature and need to add coke to the fire …..the coke is from a previous fire and not completely clean and so adds contamination ….I am with Alan about using electric…. I would get and induction forge if I was on the grid….
Joshua States Posted January 25, 2025 Posted January 25, 2025 A short update on my process. After discussing this with Matt P and JJ Simon, I tried a completely dry weld of a billet stack and welded it at 2050*F. This weld went perfectly. The billet in the upper right, welded, re-squared, and drawn out on the right below. 1 “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
billyO Posted January 25, 2025 Posted January 25, 2025 (edited) I'm not sure how I missed this thread, but this topic came up yesterday with another smith in our shop. He's from mexico and was asking me about making damascus without flux or without cleaning the billet, because that's what he remembers seeing his grandpa do. It reminded me of a video demo we did during COVID for the NWBA: Edited January 25, 2025 by billyO speling 1 One should keep in mind, we are all both the blacksmith and iron in the fire... as always peace and love billyO
shane45 Posted July 18 Posted July 18 So the big question! Did everyone stay fluxless or did they eventually go back to flux over time. Thinking time would have really exposed this method as being superior or not.
billyO Posted July 18 Posted July 18 I can't speak for anyone else, but I try to stay fluxless when possible/practical. mostly in an effort to keep the forge floor clean. (And because I'm cheap and prefer to spend as little money as possible, and not purchasing borax helps accomplish this.) Flux allows me to be less careful with billet preparation. When forge welding flat pieces for billets, it's easy to clean and prep the pieces to allow for fluxless welding. When forge welding forged pieces for a project such as gate/railing this isn't as easy, so flux is often needed to ensure a good, solid weld. One should keep in mind, we are all both the blacksmith and iron in the fire... as always peace and love billyO
Alan Longmire Posted July 18 Posted July 18 What Billy said. It depends on what you're doing. In a gas forge with a reducing atmosphere and welding up a billet of clean flat steel with no mill scale, fluxless is the way to go. In coal or charcoal with gnarly irregular pieces, flux is a necessity.
Brian Dougherty Posted July 20 Posted July 20 I concur with Billy and Alan. I have a gas forge and don't use flux unless I have some sort of gap that I can't close prior to welding. -Brian
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now