Faye Posted January 3, 2024 Posted January 3, 2024 This blade is from a Damascus billet I made last week. I had it hand sanded to 600 and cleaned the heck out of the blade with soap and water and rubbing alcohol before putting it in a fresh ferric chloride mix. It came out completely black, so I used a hard flat backer and sanded it with 2000 grit to bring the pattern out. I don't know what happened, but this is hands down the ugliest etch I've ever done. It's hard to photograph, but there are blotches that look like their 120 grit, and all the q-tip scrub marks from etching are still visible in certain light. Some particulars. I used 1080 and 15n20 from new jersey steel barons for the Damascus, and had no issues or abnormalities with it. My ferric chloride was newly mixed, but the unopened bottles had been in my shop for at least a year and have seen below freezing a few times. Any advice on what might have caused this, and if there is anything I could do to fix it is seriously appreciated.
Joshua States Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 (edited) You are the second person in as many weeks that has let me know of a bad etching problem with this combo of steels. The only differences are he didn't buy his steel from NJSB and his ferric is homemade. I don't think freezing has much of an adverse effect on it's etching ability, but what do I know? Personally, I think it's a bad batch of 15N20 because there are almost zero shiny bits, but a few questions first. How long was the etch cycle and how many cycles.? What is the process between cycles? Is the etch agitated or not? 7 hours ago, Faye said: all the q-tip scrub marks Please explain Edited January 4, 2024 by Joshua States “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Faye Posted January 4, 2024 Author Posted January 4, 2024 1 hour ago, Joshua States said: Please explain Every 5-10 minutes I take the blade out and gently rub the black oxides off with a q-tip. I etched it a little longer than normal, probably 40 minutes. No agitation, but I did warm the ferric chloride up some. Like tap water warm, nothing crazy.
billyO Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 (edited) 28 minutes ago, Faye said: I did warm the ferric chloride up some Warmer temps will etch faster. I'm not necessarily saying this is the reason, but the 2 times I had something like this happen to me was: (First time) when I etched a blade in the winter and warmed up my mix (that I've been using for 5+years) that was stored outside. In the PNW winter means temps in the low 40s and IIRC it would take 3-4 30 minute cycles to get a good etch when the acid was this cold. The second time was when I lost track of time and etched for about 45 minutes (I can't remember if this was wintertime or summertime). Edited January 4, 2024 by billyO One should keep in mind, we are all both the blacksmith and iron in the fire... as always peace and love billyO
Alan Longmire Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 11 hours ago, Faye said: Every 5-10 minutes I take the blade out and gently rub the black oxides off with a q-tip. I use a clean paper towel, it's easier to get a smooth removal of oxides with a larger surface. You sure you got the ferric mix right? That looks like the result of a too-strong blend to me.
Dan Hertzson Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 1 hour ago, Alan Longmire said: I use a clean paper towel I have always used an old toothbrush for this. Seems to work pretty well and is better than tossing them once they start to show some wear... 1
Joshua States Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 (edited) 2 hours ago, Alan Longmire said: I use a clean paper towel, it's easier to get a smooth removal of oxides with a larger surface. You sure you got the ferric mix right? That looks like the result of a too-strong blend to me. I'm also in the paper towel crowd. I just rinse in running water and wipe dry before going in for the next/last etch. Too strong a mix might explain why the 15N20 seems to be almost as black as the 1080. Edited January 4, 2024 by Joshua States “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Faye Posted January 4, 2024 Author Posted January 4, 2024 Ok, if the mix was off at all it would have been on the strong side. So I added more water, and after cleaning the blade up I tried again. I ditched the q-tips and just used paper towels. It still etched completely black so I started using 600 grit sandpaper with a hard backer to take the black off every 5 minutes. Results were more even, sort of, but overall the etch is super shallow and still not presentable. I have some straight muriatic acid, is it feasible to try it in place of the ferric?
Jim White Posted January 4, 2024 Posted January 4, 2024 Maybe try some super strong instant coffee and see what happens.
doc blues Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 When you say you use a hard backer , exactly what do you mean. I use steel with 1000 grit paper.
Faye Posted January 5, 2024 Author Posted January 5, 2024 5 minutes ago, doc blues said: When you say you use a hard backer , exactly what do you mean. A piece of flat wood or steel. Anything hard and flat that insures I only touch the high spots with the sand paper.
Joshua States Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 I'm still leaning toward a bad batch of 15N20, but here goes. I don't sand between cyles. I just rinse and wipe dry. Sanding reduces the height of the 15N20 and what you are trying to achieve is deep topography. Sanding reduces that. "completely black" is also something I'm not really looking for. With a static etch, the oxides build up and longer isn't necessarily better because the acid has to work through the oxide layer. This is why I time my etch cycles and do no more and no less. After my last cycle, (usually the third one) I just rinse well and don't wipe. I let it dry over night and sand it lightly the next day. Then I decide if I want to blue it or use the coffee to make the black areas really black. Run your finger across the surface and tell us whether you can feel the topography. Unless you have pretty thick callouses on your finger tips, you should be able to feel the uneven surface. What does your etch tank look like? “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
billyO Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 1 hour ago, Joshua States said: After my last cycle, (usually the third one) I just rinse well and don't wipe. I let it dry over night and sand it lightly the next day. My only suggestion to this technique (more for future newbies who might read this, Joshua) would be to spray with windex or use baking soda with your rinse to neutralize the acid during the rinsing. Also doing this after the coffee etch (if you do it) is a good idea to avoid the yellowing that often happens to the 15N20 when using the coffee technique 11 hours ago, Dan Hertzson said: I have always used an old toothbrush for this. Seems to work pretty well and is better than tossing them once they start to show some wear... This is what I do as well now. I used 0000 steel wool in the past, but these end up as a rusted pile of dust afterwards, and I got tired of having to keep buying more. I've also been known to use my gloved finger at times too. One should keep in mind, we are all both the blacksmith and iron in the fire... as always peace and love billyO
Faye Posted January 5, 2024 Author Posted January 5, 2024 1 hour ago, Joshua States said: Run your finger across the surface and tell us whether you can feel the topography. Unless you have pretty thick callouses on your finger tips, you should be able to feel the uneven surface. What does your etch tank look like? There is no topography to it. Usually I use a glass jar for my etchant, but it wasn't tall enough for this knife so I found a plastic jug that was. 1 hour ago, Joshua States said: I'm still leaning toward a bad batch of 15N20, but here goes. I don't disagree. This is the second billet of Damascus I've had issues with. The first one wasn't this bad though.
Joshua States Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 That should work fine. BTW, if you are going to keep your acid in a clear container, paint the container with a can of spray paint. The color doesn't matter, but you want it opaque. Sunlight will weaken the acid. Which may just be the problem here...... “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Joshua States Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 31 minutes ago, billyO said: to spray with windex or use baking soda with your rinse to neutralize the acid during the rinsing. I used to spray with windex, but I found that it caused some splotchiness in subsequent etching cycles, so I stopped using it between etches. Now I just use running water and give it a good rinse for 30 seconds or so. Never have a problem with that. 1 “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Bill Schmalhofer Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 I had a very similar issue a while ago (although not as extreme as yours) when I tried the 1084/15N20 combo (mine also from NJSB). Did a post on here about it and, through lots of trouble shooting and helpful suggestions (some posted here again), got absolutely nowhere. Ended up snapping that blade in several places to see if there was an issue with grain structure causing the problem (there didn't appear to be). Still have a big section of that billet sitting around as I don't feel like going through the work to make a blade and not have it etch. Went back to my "normal" combo of 80CrV2/15N20 (same batch of 15N20!) and had no problems. Never did figure out what was the problem, but since then, I have been hesitant to go back to 1084... I'll be very interested to see if you ever figure out what the problem is / was.
Faye Posted January 5, 2024 Author Posted January 5, 2024 4 hours ago, Bill Schmalhofer said: Ended up snapping that blade I'm just about to that point. It's a commissioned blade and it looks terrible, I'd rather feed it to muriatic acid than anything else right now. I rummaged around and found a piece of Damascus from several years ago and etched it in the ferric I've been trying to use on the blade. Amazingly, it reacted perfectly normal. So I'm going to go make some more Damascus from my newest order of steel and see what happens. 1
Dick Sexstone Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 Is the tang Damascus like the blade? I would try some battery acid and see how it responds ..... the pattern will not come up as strong if you have left the tang soft but should etch without the blotches. If the battery acid works resand your blade and wearing a latex glove sand the blade with some 1500 grit sandpaper using the battery acid to keep it wet.... use baking soda to halt the etch ......I hope you have not broken the blade yet......
Joshua States Posted January 5, 2024 Posted January 5, 2024 6 hours ago, Faye said: I'm just about to that point. It's a commissioned blade and it looks terrible, I'd rather feed it to muriatic acid than anything else right now. I rummaged around and found a piece of Damascus from several years ago and etched it in the ferric I've been trying to use on the blade. Amazingly, it reacted perfectly normal. So I'm going to go make some more Damascus from my newest order of steel and see what happens. So the acid is still good. Was this second piece also the 1080/15N20 combination? If so, the steel is bad “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Faye Posted January 6, 2024 Author Posted January 6, 2024 4 hours ago, Dick Sexstone said: Is the tang Damascus like the blade? I would try some battery acid and see how it responds It is. If I can get some battery acid I will give that a try. I haven't broke the blade yet, but it's likely destined to be jewelry or something. I made a new billet today and etched the first cut off. Here is a comparison with the end cut off of the billet from last week. Same jar of ferric, same finish, same cleaning process, same steel composition, same etch time. So the steel seems to be the problem. 1
Joshua States Posted January 6, 2024 Posted January 6, 2024 2 hours ago, Faye said: So the steel seems to be the problem. I concur. That left one will make some nice W's........just sayin' “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Bill Schmalhofer Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 On 1/5/2024 at 8:11 PM, Faye said: So the steel seems to be the problem. So now the $1,000,000 question (or at least a couple hundred); what about this steel made it "bad"?... Another two questions: Is the steel that etched from NJSB? And if it is, is it a different lot from the two that didn't? As a biochemist, I have to track lots of my reagents that I use in my experiments. Only started doing this in knife making after my run in with my etching issues. I know NJSB lists lot analysis on their website, but if you had leftover pieces of the two steels that don't etch, it would be interesting (and unfortunately $$$$) to get them analyzed to see what is in them. Good luck with the new billet. On 1/5/2024 at 10:26 PM, Joshua States said: That left one will make some nice W's........just sayin' I concur with this too .
Bob Bryenton Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 My experience. I found the heat treat makes a huge difference on the quality of my etch. that and making sure I have sanded off all of the decarb. Bob Bryenton Solar Storm https://www.solarstorm.ca bob@solarstorm.ca
Joshua States Posted January 8, 2024 Posted January 8, 2024 (edited) 10 hours ago, Bill Schmalhofer said: what about this steel made it "bad"? Mettalurgically, I can't tell you. I don't have that skill set. As a knife maker who is fond of stating the obvious, what's wrong is this: On 1/4/2024 at 10:10 AM, Joshua States said: the 15N20 seems to be almost as black as the 1080. And the 1080 isn't really black, it's gray. It almost looks like 1070 or something. I stopped using 1080/84 a long time ago in favor of 1095 It etches blacker, performs better, and doesn't cost much more. Edited January 8, 2024 by Joshua States “So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.” The only bad experience is the one from which you learn nothing. Josh http://www.dosgatosdesignsllc.com/#! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdJMFMqnbLYqv965xd64vYg J.States Bladesmith | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/dos.gatos.71 https://www.etsy.com/shop/JStatesBladesmith
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now